Quick Links
The TV show Lost used to be practically made with the aim to make all of its viewers really feel precisely that: lost! The whole idea behind the show is that questions had been offered faster than any individual may in finding solutions and that in case you did manage to get a solution to a question, it handiest came with a dozen more questions! Fans and target audience participants truly struggled to deal with never knowing what was occurring within their favourite show, and the show if truth be told managed to lose a lot of audience due to its enigmatic nature. Even when the show ended, viewers were left with dozens of questions unanswered, which wound up infuriating a lot of other folks.
The level is that we had been continuously wondering the whole thing whilst staring at Lost. When the writers gave us no solutions to our questions, we started seeking to determine them out for ourselves... "What is the smoke monster?" "Where did that foot statue come from?" "Who are the others?" "Why does Widmore care about the island?" "Why can't Desmond leave the island?" We had so many questions that we began to bet what the answers could be.
Now, obviously, many of these theories have been confirmed fallacious (we're going to point those ones out) -- the show ended seven years in the past, and plenty of of those mysteries wound up being solved. But they are simply so entertaining that we needed to proportion them with you! Here are 15 Lost fan theories that wound up making more sense than the show did itself:
Widmore and Psychic Marketing
Charles Widmore used to be a beautiful vicious guy, but now not just about as vicious as this fan concept hypothesized. These fanatics believed that the plane crash wasn't actual and that the survivors had been, in a sense, brainwashed. Charles flew them to the island and made them consider they'd crashed to test out a new psychic marketing tactic he sought after to employ in his business endeavors. However, issues went awry when the survivors met "the others," who were Charles's employees, and were given even worse when the survivors discovered the pseudo-runway that the others had built. Additional clues that made this idea make sense integrated the brainwashing chamber and everybody's trippy "hallucinations" that looked as if it would introduce truth in dream shape. This theory was once a cute one however was absolutely fallacious. It was formulated proper around the time Widmore was introduced in Desmond's flashbacks, so it used to be definitely inventive given how little we knew about him -- but still fallacious!
Nanobots
Many fanatics thought of this concept at some point in time, and those that did idea that they had to be the most unusual fan out there for considering it up all through themselves. But guess what: you were improper. On so many levels. When the smoke monster was once first offered, everybody concept, "IT'S MADE OF NANOBOTS, NOT SMOKE!" someday. But that would have been mega-lazy since Michael Crichton (a robust supply of inspiration for the show) printed a e-book a couple of cloud of nanobots about three years before. Damon Lindelof went on digital camera several occasions in interviews announcing, "I don't know how many times you can go on record saying that the black smoke is not made up of nanobots before you stop getting asked that question." Fans thought it might be the writers looking to lead them off course and have been insistent because it appeared the nanobots have been taking photos of Eko's recollections, but they have been completely (obviously) incorrect.
Dharma Created the Smoke Monster
This principle was clearly proven false once John Locke printed himself as the Man in Black in Disguise at the finish of season five -- and then, at the starting of season 6, when Smokey the monster destroyed everybody in sight. But again earlier than then, like long ago in season two, there was a idea that The Dharma Initiative used to be the usage of the island as a form of redemption recycling plant: they wanted to sort through newcomers to search out the damaged and broken other people, then attempt to bring them again from their messed up techniques. The Smoke Monster used to be invented by them as a measure of quality keep an eye on: to determine just how corrupted they have been and in the event that they had been worthy of Dharma's efforts. It was an unsuitable idea, however it used to be a in point of fact good one -- particularly after the episode where Eko is confronted through the monster, most effective to be left by myself.
Two Smoke Monsters?
So we know that the smoke monster is in reality The Man in Black (aka, Cerberus) going right into a metaphysical form so as to terrorize individuals who might side with Jacob or hinder his eventual goals of escaping the island, striking out the light at the middle of the island, and creating chaos in the world. But that doesn't truly give an explanation for all of Cerberus's actions previous in the show... like, why did he move after Juliet and Kate in season three? He'd need Kate on his aspect to get off the island, and Juliet intended nothing to him. This fan concept posited that there have been in reality TWO smoke monsters: a benevolent Cerberus, trying to win the survivors over, and a malevolent one seeking to kill off good islanders... like THE DEVIL! It would certainly explain a lot of the weird stuff the smoke monster did, however that can all truly be chalked as much as the writers desiring a handy suspenseful tournament.
Lost Takes Place in the Distant Future
Alright, this principle was once also confirmed false, but undergo with us a moment because it's a truly intricate one. Fans made this idea about a yr after the show released: the plane crashes, like standard, and everyone on board dies. The crash is salvaged, and those that we know had their our bodies and brains put in ice. Then, many years and centuries later, the ones brains are brought back and the survivors awaken. This futuristic society comes to a decision they'll undergo much less trauma assimilating to their new global if they are introduced to it slowly by way of events on the island, fairly than waking up Captain America-style. We're now not entirely positive that's true, but whatever... And we additionally question how numerous this "futuristic" stuff is so previous, like hatches from the Nineteen Seventies and wood ships from the 1800s. So clearly, that is all false... however it will have made a captivating story if they could have made the futuristic stuff look cool and sound plausible.
(*15*)The Man in Black Took Over Aaron's BodySo you know the way The Man in Black is just right at leaping into the skins of the recently deceased? He does so with Christian Shephard, and then he manages to do it once more with John Locke. But what if the ones don't seem to be the simplest two sufferers he had? Some lovers theorize that Claire needed to be more watchful of her child as a result of when the airplane crashed, her child died while in utero. There, the Man in Black took over his baby body before he was once even born. He did the entirety he may to escape the island, but when he did, he discovered he wasn't in a position to be really loose because Jacob was once still alive, and the gentle on the island hadn't long gone out. So he has to return to the island -- he jumps into Jeremy Bentham's corpse and waits until the frame is again on the island to reanimate. A truly trippy principle -- but most likely one that may just cling some truth to it?
Walt's Purpose
Remember Walt from seasons one and two (after which his random appearances later in the sequence)? Remember how he had some form of supernatural powers? He without a doubt had a unusual thing with birds happening, like each and every time he were given angry, birds would flock to him in a suicidal manner. What was up with that? We by no means got a solution! Well, some fanatics had a concept: that he would grow as much as rule the island. Well, when you noticed the post-season 6 DVD further, Walt may nonetheless pass on to just do that. But others concept that Walt would develop as much as grow to be Lance Reddick, Widmore's assistant who was once very a professional about the island. Well, that didn't happen -- although it will've been really cool. Maybe he may just take on that form of function in the long run of the Lost universe, however we're going to never know except they make some Lost spin-off sequel (we are having a look at you, Netflix)...
Pregnancy on Island
One of the unanswered questions at the finish of the day was why women that were given pregnant on the island never survived their time period. We discover that no matter went unsuitable most probably happened after The Incident that befell in 1977 (Ethan was once born on the island, so no matter went wrong came about after his birth). Well, some fanatics have a theory: the Dharma Initiative was once selective in who could come to the island before The Incident, and they were most likely even more selective afterward. Then, when Ben took over control, NO ONE new got here to the island, except the occasional recruit like Juliet (and she was once an extraordinary case, when you keep in mind). So the genetic pool was shrinking more and more with every passing yr. This may cause a lot of issues of pregnancies, together with being able to carry a baby to term. This is why Claire and Sun had no issues (as a result of they were from off the island), but each and every different lady on Juliet's table died -- a probably true theory, though we predict the genetic pool needed to stew another couple of generations to get that muddied.
The Time Loop Theory
Alright, cling on to your seats: this idea is about to get mad intricate and scientific on you. Heads up: it is fallacious, so don't be thinking it's important to perceive this concept to know the show. BUT it might had been a popular choice to what wound up happening. So let's consider that the incident at the Dharma Swan Station causes some tie between the button pushing and time. Ben and Richard rig it so that each 108 minutes, when the button is driven, the island is going again in time 108 mins. So the island is stuck on this time loop that originated someday in the '90s or so, explaining why Locke good points his ability to stroll and ladies are unable to hold young children, and so on. But when the button ceases being pushed, weird issues occur as time progresses as same old. It would give an explanation for why other people like Richard do not age... however leaves out such a lot of key main points that it's not believable.
The Show Was All About Desmond & Penny
This one could be considered one of our favorite fan theories as a result of, in a way, it was once roughly correct. This theory suggests that none of the other survivors or events matter at all -- this story is all about Desmond and Penny's arc. It kind of makes sense in a way: Penny's father Charles is the one that inspires Desmond to make his crusing go back and forth around the world, which in the end leads him to the island -- fans argue that Charles did it intentionally to check if Desmond was a worthy spouse for his daughter. Then Desmond eventually makes the aircraft crash via failing to push the button, Desmond brings the newbs to the hatch, Desmond gets the freighter to return to the island, then Penny saves the Oceanic 6 and Desmond from the island, however then Desmond returns to the island and dies combating to give protection to all those again home. Perhaps it's not the true pressure of the story, but... the idea isn't incorrect both.
Purgatory
We do not understand how many times we will be able to say it. LOST WAS NOT PURGATORY, IT NEVER WAS PURGATORY, AND NO PART OF IT INCLUDED PURGATORY! Sure, a large number of lovers will argue with us here and declare that the "flash-sideways" in season six was once purgatory and that the passengers had been dead all alongside. (We remind you that the whole thing that came about on the island -- and rancid the island, when people escaped -- in reality did occur in the international of the show.) When they all died in their own occasions, their spirits convened in some non secular place between lifestyles and whatever comes next. BUT THAT IS NOT PURGATORY! Purgatory, as outlined by means of the Catholic church, is the place individuals who are not pure sufficient to visit heaven undergo punishments for his or her sins -- kind of like a brief version of hell...
Hell
Furthermore, THE ISLAND WAS NOT HELL -- even though some fans posited that The Dharma Initiative found a way to succeed in hell and find out about it, which brought about a large downside in Hell gaining access to Earth. The principle appeared plausible to some enthusiasts; this model of hell was once made actual and tangible and gave other people hope coupled with sadness, gain coupled with immeasurable loss. It would provide an explanation for why new lifestyles could not be introduced onto the island (as a result of they were all already in a plane of the dead). It would also give an explanation for why these characters have been continuously caught in flashbacks in their previous, reliving some of their most painful, shameful, and embarrassing moments. But it wouldn't explain how folks had been in a position to depart hell or what happened when someone died in hell? Would they cross to heaven? Nikki and Paulo certain did not seem heaven-bound, so where did they cross? There were too many holes in the theory!
Garden of Eden
Once more, then we're going to get off of the religious heaven-hell-purgatory nonsense. While some fanatics concept that the lovers were residing in a model of hell, others believed that they'd in fact crashed onto the authentic Garden of Eden. In the Bible, the Garden of Eden is where Adam and Eve are created (have in mind when the skeletons are found in the episode "House of the Rising Sun," and the survivors dub them Adam and Eve?) and then refrained from from after sinning and bringing corruption into the lawn. Well, some believed that those survivors found it again -- it gave the impression of a total paradise, however the black smoke represented the corruption the predecessors wrought. It used to be an interesting concept, evidently, one that roughly makes sense! After all, there are TONS of references to the e-book of Genesis in the collection. But we're certain a tale like this could not have been sustained beyond 2 seasons, maximum.
Everything Was a Messed Up Game
This idea was absolutely correct, excluding for a few minor details. It additionally utterly belittled the roles of the primary solid in the ultimate tale and gave Jacob and The Man in Black slightly an excessive amount of credit. Remember when Jacob introduced the boat wearing Richard Alpert to the island? The Man in Black and Jacob spend the episode trying to win over Richard's loyalties and soul, Jacob sooner or later prevailing. So what if the complete collection is truly necessarily that: a recreation or competition wherein the two are competing, and the survivors that we all know and love are simply pawns and chess items? Jacob doesn't care if he loses his Eko pawn piece somewhere in the sport so long as the king piece, Jack, is saved safe. In essence, this principle is kind of true -- nevertheless it robs the characters of the energy of agency, which is what Jacob tells all his fans is maximum necessary. Having the choice to do one thing or now not do it's what life is all about, and his most effective probability at profitable the recreation is to wish his case is powerful sufficient that his followers select him.
The Light at the Center of the Island
THIS IS OUR FAVORITE THEORY, one that may just doubtlessly still be true and make EVERYTHING make such a lot more sense! That light at the middle of the island, you already know, the one Desmond and Jack died to offer protection to -- it was shrouded in mystery like this natural phenomenon that was someway essential however none folks truly understood why. You know what it is? TIME. Jacob's mom says that the mild is one thing everyone has a few of, but everyone at all times lusts for more of. The show emphasized the function of time so much, with pendulums, hourglasses, digital clocks, metronomes, and watches -- CONSTANTLY. We're additionally constantly watching how time laws us all with flashbacks, flash-forwards, or even flash-sideways to varieties of parallel dimensions (what some people posit "heavenly" reviews may quantity to). If The Man in Black places out this mild, he extinguishes time for everybody in every single place, and the international as we comprehend it ends. But if it is protected, time is going on for us all. IT ALL MAKES SENSE.
Sources: vulture.com; gizmodo.com; lostpedia.wikia.com
ncG1vNJzZmivp6x7tbTEq6CcoJWowW%2BvzqZmsKeiobFusc2tnKuskZ67rrHNrWZqbV2hvLTAjJ%2BYp2WknbKwvsieqmasmJbBbrnApJxmpZ%2Bnsm6%2FxKeqnmWkna6vedOhnGarmKTEcA%3D%3D